📝 Islands of Coherence - Adapt, Survive & Flourish

Islands of Coherence are small groups, communities, or networks within a larger system that build enough trust, shared purpose, and understanding to learn, adapt, and act collectively. These groups can form within organisations, professions, communities, supply chains, or social movements. They are not always formal teams and may not appear on an organisational chart. Often, they arise when people identify a common concern, responsibility, or opportunity that the broader system has not yet recognised.

An Island of Coherence forms when people begin to see the world together.

They share stories.
They compare experience.
They test ideas.
They build trust.
They develop a common language.
They notice patterns others miss.
They support each other when the wider system is confused, defensive or fragmented.

In the Adapt, Survive and Flourish framework, Islands of Coherence are significant because they illustrate how adaptive capacity initially develops. Large systems seldom change entirely at once. Instead, change usually starts in smaller, coherent areas where people can collaborate, experiment securely, and bring new understanding into the broader system.

Why Islands of Coherence Matter

Complex systems are often too large, noisy or politically constrained to learn as a whole.

A large organisation may have formal values, policies and strategies, but still lack a shared understanding. People may work in silos, protect their own patch, repeat inherited assumptions, or avoid difficult conversations.

An Island of Coherence creates a different kind of space.

Inside it, people can:

Speak more openly and honestly.
Test ideas before they harden into positions.
Challenge assumptions without destroying trust.
Build shared understanding across boundaries.
Preserve knowledge that might otherwise be lost.
Develop new practices that can later influence the wider system.

These islands are not escapes from reality. At their best, they are places where reality can be faced more clearly.

Islands of Coherence and Learning

An Island of Coherence is a form of social learning.

It is built through repeated interaction, mutual trust and shared attention. Over time, the group develops its own language, memory and rhythm. Members come to understand not only what others think, but also why they think that way.

This allows deeper learning to occur.

People are more willing to admit uncertainty.
They are more willing to surface weak signals.
They are more willing to say, “I may be wrong.”
They are more willing to explore what the wider system is avoiding.

This is why Islands of Coherence are closely related to Ba, dialogue, Gemba, psychological safety and communities of practice.

Examples

In the book Adapt, Survive and Flourish, the Tuesday Night Survivors Club is an Island of Coherence. It is not a formal organisation, project team or committee. It is a group of experienced people who meet regularly to make sense of complexity, share knowledge and help others act more wisely.

Fred’s local regenerative agriculture group is another example. Farmers visit each other’s properties, compare experiments, share failures, identify patterns and learn together in context. Their shared purpose is not merely individual improvement, but healthier land, healthier communities and more resilient farming systems.

Within an organization, an Island of Coherence can develop around a team such as data stewards, product specialists, clinicians, engineers, operators, or customer-facing staff. These groups often start to recognize a recurring issue more distinctly than the formal system itself does.

The Risk

Islands of Coherence are powerful, but they are also fragile.

They can become isolated, romanticised or defensive. If they disconnect from the wider system, they may become enclaves rather than sources of renewal. If they are absorbed too quickly, their coherence can be destroyed by formalisation, politics or premature scaling.

The challenge is not simply to create islands. It is to help them connect, mature and influence the wider system without losing the trust and shared meaning that made them valuable.

In Plain Terms

An Island of Coherence is a small place where people make sense together before the larger system is ready to change.

It is where new understanding forms, gains strength and begins to spread.

Related Concepts

Ba
Social Ecology
Dialogue
Psychological Safety
Communities of Practice
Adaptive Capacity
Gemba
Shared Mental Models
Organisational Learning
Regenerative Agriculture

For more information, see